 |
Magazine covers carried lurid pictures of murder,
crime and sex. |
OTTAWA | Oct. 1, 2004 — It
was something in Michel Brisebois' gut — an instinct honed by 25 years
in the biz — that told him the dealer on the phone had something he
might like to look at. In person.
"My first reaction was, 'Wow. We will never see this again,' "
Brisebois says.
Before him were boxes of manuscripts, provocative photographs, celebrity
stills from black-and-white movies, colour proofs, original water-colour
cover art, newspaper clippings and uncirculated copies of some of the
trashiest crime magazines Brisebois had ever laid eyes on.
And they were all Canadian.
At the time, as rare books curator for Library and Archives Canada, he
sensed that this was an important acquisition — trashy, but important.
"I'd been in this business a long time and I hadn't seen them.
So, I knew this must be pretty rare."
'As a national library we have an
obligation to collect this material, not make a moral judgment on
the content.' |
The magazines flourished during the Second World War, when the federal
government banned the import of all non-essential goods, including British
and American periodicals. Canadian publishers like Toronto's Al Valentine
and the Ruby brothers — Mo and Lou — raced to fill the void
left in the magazine racks of the nation.
Daring Crime Cases, for example, sold for 15 cents a copy and
blared headlines like "Trailing Toronto's Love Slayer: True Facts
from Official Files." Then there was "The Strange Story of Vancouver
Cult" or "Trapping Winnipeg’s Pock-Marked Frankenstein."
Another mag, Factual Detective Stories, offered the reader
"Terror in the Sanitarium" and "Trapped by the Lie Detector:
Plunder of the Bank-Cracking Beauty."
Naturally, the pages were also rife with crimes of passion, like this
one from Startling Crimes magazine: "Rather than see her
wed another, he would see her dead. His plan was simple and effective.
Yet it was no more effective than the hangman's noose that snuffed out
his life in the grey dawn of the morning of March 2, 1945, in Bordeaux
Jail in Montreal."
Even though the magazines emphasized Canadian names and locations, Brisebois
says, "ethics weren't their big thing."
The editors were "trading" material back and forth with American
publishers all the time.
"They were taking stuff, then they changed the locations, changed
the dates and changed the names."
The facts and details about the particular crimes were, however, surprisingly
accurate.
Brisebois says he anticipated the "polite reservations" of
some of his colleagues when he proposed acquiring what has been dubbed
The Valentine Collection. Indeed, some eyes did roll to the ceiling when
he made his pitch. But, in the end, they bought it.
"For about $35,000," he says.
 |
Daring Crime Cases was one series within
The Valentine Collection. |
"As a national library we have an obligation to collect this material,
not make a moral judgment on the content."
Brisebois had also banked on the collection being important to researchers.
His instincts proved to be right again. Professors Carolyn Strange and
Doris Loo delved into The Valentine Collection and produced a book, True
Crime, True North: The Golden Age of Canadian Pulp Magazines.
Other academics also came to his support. Some called the acquisition
an important slice of Canadian culture.
"The magazines are a reflection of us," Brisebois says. "It's
a reflection of what a percentage of people read in the '40s. It wasn't
the criminals reading this. It was the very nice people with nice homes
and three kids.
'The magazines
are a reflection of us. It wasn't the criminals reading this. It was
the very nice people with
nice homes
and three kids.' |
"Also, it was the war period, so not many movies were coming out.
Not much literature. Not very much else shows that seedy part of us that
people like to hide. Especially in English Canada, which was much more
Puritan. If we don't have these, how are we going to document that side
of us? This is a survival collection."
This golden era of Canadian pulp publishing didn't survive the '40s.
In 1945-55, "there was mounting hysteria over literature for young
adults," according to John Bell who deals with social and cultural
manuscripts at National Library and Archives. Some churches, Parent-Teacher
Associations and politicians began pressuring the federal government to
censor paperbacks, crime magazines and comic books.
"There was major hysteria about these things," Bell says. "There
were public burnings. It was a moral panic."
Backbench member of Parliament E. Davie Fulton sponsored a bill that
passed in 1949, which made it an offence to make, print, publish, distribute,
sell, or own "any magazine, periodical or book which exclusively
or substantially comprises matter depicting pictorially the commission
of crimes, real or fictitious."
So if you had been reading this stuff, you got rid of it fast. That's
what drew Michel Brisebois to these mags in the first place.
"I like material that is unusual ... whether it's underground or
popular. The material you didn't keep is what you want to see."
John Bell also says this is a significant piece of Canadian history.
He is working on a web site for Library and Archives Canada devoted to
Canadian pulps between 1945 and 1955, which should be up and running by
next year.
"We are swimming in American culture, he says. "It's important
that we explore our own popular culture. Even if it's seedy."
|