Decisions and Orders

A | B | C | D | E | F | G | H | I | J | K | L | M | N | O | P | Q | R | S | T | U | V | W | X | Y | Z

A

ADDERALL XR

Decisions – Board Orders

Supplementary Order - (PMPRB-06-D5-ADDERALL XR), May 5, 2010 (PDF)
Board Order on the Merits - (PMPRB-06-D5-ADDERALL XR), August 27, 2008 (PDF)
Admissibility of Evidence - (PMPRB-06-D4-ADDERALL XR), July 16, 2008 (PDF)
Merits - (PMPRB-06-D3-ADDERALL XR), April 10, 2008 (PDF)
Pre-Patent Motion - (PMPRB-06-D1-ADDERALL XR), December 15, 2006 (PDF)

Notice of Hearing (PDF)

AIROMIR

Decisions – Board Order

Voluntary Compliance Undertaking, April 2007 (PDF)
Board Order - (PMPRB-06-D2-AIROMIR), May 14, 2007 (PDF)

Notice of Hearing (PDF)

Statement of Allegations of Board Staff

APO-SALVENT

Decisions

Application for Leave to Intervene (ratiopharm Inc.) - (PMPRB-08-D1-APO-SALVENT), October 27, 2008 (PDF)

Notice of Hearing (PDF)

Statement of Allegations of Board Staff (Severed)

APOTEX

Decisions – Board Order

Preliminary Motions - (PMPRB-08-D1-APOTEX), October 27, 2008 (PDF)

Notice of Hearing (PDF)

Notice of Application (PDF)

Top of page

B

BAXALTA CANADA CORPORATION

Response: April 29, 2016 (PDF - 272 kb)
Panel Orders with regards to Scheduling: April 11, 2016 (PDF - 207 kb)
Notice of Hearing (PDF - 78 kb)
Notice of Application (PDF - 802 kb)

Top of page

C

CELGENE

For the decisions in the Celgene Corporation matter, please see Thalomid.

CONCERTA

Decisions – Board Order

Voluntary Compliance Undertaking - April 1, 2009 (PDF)
Board Order - (PMPRB-06-D1-CONCERTA), April 28, 2009 (PDF)

Notice of Hearing (PDF)

COPAXONE – 2013 (Redetermination)

Decisions – Board Order

Board Order (PMPRB-13-D1-COPAXONE Redetermination 2013), February 14, 2014 (PDF)
Voluntary Compliance Undertaking (PDF)

Notice of Hearing (PDF), June 28, 2013

Abridged Amended Statement of Allegations of Board Staff (PDF)

COPAXONE – 2010 (Redetermination)

Decisions – Board Order

Judicial Review
- Federal Court – (Justice Zinn) (2013 FC 448), April 30, 2013
- Federal Court – Return of monies paid into the Consolidated Revenue Fund (Justice Zinn) (2013 FC 500), May 14, 2013
Decision/Reasons - (PMPRB-2010-D3-Copaxone), February 23, 2012 (PDF)
Board Order - (PMPRB-2010-D3-Copaxone), February, 2012 (PDF)
Decision/Reasons (on Voluntary Compliance Undertaking – June 24, 2010) (PDF)
Decision/Reasons - (PMPRB-2010-D1-COPAXONE), May 6, 2010 (PDF)

COPAXONE- 2008

Decisions – Board Order

Board Order - (PMPRB-06-D3-COPAXONE), May 12, 2008 (PDF)
Decision/Reasons - (PMPRB-06-D3-COPAXONE), May 12, 2008 (PDF)
Merits - (PMPRB-06-D2-COPAXONE), February 25, 2008 (PDF)
Judicial Review
- Federal Court - Prothonotary Milcynski (2008 FC 1091), September 30, 2008
- Federal Court - Judicial Review (Justice Hughes) (2009 FC 1155), November 12, 2009
- Federal Court - Quantum of Costs to Teva (Justice Hughes) (2009 FC 1206), November 24, 2009

Notice of Hearing (PDF)

Top of page

D

DOVOBET

Decisions – Board Order

Board Order - (PMPRB-04-D4-DOVOBET), September 18, 2007 (PDF)
Judicial Review
- Federal Court decision in LEO Pharma (2007 FC 306)
Board's Decisions and Reasons - (PMPRB-04-D2-DOVOBET), April 19, 2006 (PDF)

Notice of Hearing (PDF)

Statement of Allegations of Board Staff (PDF)

Top of page

E

EVRA

Decisions – Board Order

Voluntary Compliance Undertaking - March 1, 2005 (PDF)
Voluntary Compliance Undertaking - February 8, 2005 (PDF)
Board Order - (PMPRB-04-D1-EVRA), February 21, 2005 (PDF)
Joint Submission - February 8, 2005 (PDF)

Notice of Hearing (PDF)

Statement of Allegations of Board Staff (PDF)

Top of page

F

FASTURTEC

Decisions – Board Order

Voluntary Compliance Undertaking - June 21, 2004
Board Order - (PMPRB-04-D1-FASTUREC), June 28, 2004
Submission of SANOFI-SYNTHÉLABO CANADA INC, June 25, 2004 (PDF)
Submission of Board Staff, June 25, 2004

Notice of Hearing

Statement of Allegations of Board Staff

Top of page

G

GALDERMA CANADA INC.

Response: April 22, 2016 (PDF - 1.49 MB)
Panel Order with regards to Scheduling: April 20, 2016 (PDF - 213 kb)
Panel Order with regards to Scheduling: March 10, 2016 (PDF - 110 kb)
Notice of Hearing (PDF - 150 kb)
Notice of Application (PDF - 784 kb)

Top of page

H

HABITROL

PMPRB-94-D2/HABITROL, October 24, 1994 (PDF)
Voluntary Compliance Undertaking, October 18, 1994 (PDF)
Federal Court of Appeal Order A-209-94, June 7, 1994 (PDF)
Federal Court of Appeal Reasons A-209-94, June 7, 1994 (PDF)
Federal Court Reasons (1994 CarswellNat 859), May 3, 1994 (PDF)
Federal Court Order (1994 CarswellNat 859), April 29, 1994 (PDF)
PMPRB-94-D1/HABITROL, February 1, 1994 (PDF)

Top of page

N

NEULASTA

Decisions – Board Order

Voluntary Compliance Undertaking - October 13, 2009 (PDF)
Board Order - (PMPRB-09-D1-NEULASTA), October 21, 2009 (PDF)

Notice of Hearing (PDF)

Statement of Allegations of Board Staff (Severed) (PDF)

NICODERM

Decisions – Board Order

Decision on the Merits - (PMPRB-99-D10-NICODERM), April 9, 2010 (PDF)
Motion for Particulars and Production - (PMPRB-99-D9-NICODERM), December 16, 2008 (PDF)
Continuation of Hearing - (PMPRB-99-D8-NICODERM), July 21, 2008 (PDF)
Federal Court Decision - September 2009
Federal Court Decision on HMRC (Update) - (2005 FC 1552), November 2005 (PDF)
Federal Court Decision on Jurisdiction - (2005 FC 1552), November 17, 2005
Nicoderm Federal Court Reasons and Order, April 1, 2004 (FC489) (PDF)
Ncoderm Federal Court Order, November 14, 2003 (FC 1343) (PDF)
Nicoderm Federal Court Reasons, November 14, 2003 (FC 1343) (PDF)
Decision on Jurisdiction - Part II - (PMPRB-99-D6-NICODERM), August 8, 2000 (PDF)
Interim Order Jurisdiction Part II - (PMPRB-99-D4-NICODERM), March 13, 2000 (PDF)
Document Disclosure - (PMPRB-99-D3-NICODERM), August 3, 1999 (PDF)
Jurisdiction - Part I - (PMPRB-99-D2-NICODERM), August 3, 1999 (PDF)
Board Order - (Filing schedule) - (PMPRB-99-01-NICODERM), May 27, 1999 (PDF)

Abridged Notice of Hearing (PDF)

Top of page

P

PENLAC NAIL LACQUER

Decisions – Board Order

Board Order/Merits - (PMPRB-07-D2-PENLAC), January 31, 2011 (PDF)
Decision - (PMPRB-07-D2-PENLAC), January 31, 2011 (PDF)
Motion for Production and Leave to File Reply Evidence - Decision: (PMPRB-07-D1-PENLAC), August 20, 2008 (PDF)

Notice of Hearing (PDF)

Statement of Allegations of Board Staff (Severed)

PENTACEL

Decisions – Board Order

Board Order - (PMPRB-07-D6-QUADRACEL and PENTACEL), June 14, 2012 (PDF)
Decision - (PMPRB-07-D6-QUADRACEL and PENTACEL), June 14, 2012 (PDF)
Judicial Review
- Federal Court Decision - Justice Gauthier (2011 FC 859), July 12, 2011
Board Order - (PMPRB07-D5-QUADRACEL and PENTACEL), March 16, 2010 (PDF)
Decision on the Merits - (PMPRB-07-D5-QUADRACEL and PENTACEL), as amended March 1, 2010 (PDF)
Decision on the Merits - (PMPRB-07-D5-QUADRACEL and PENTACEL), December 21, 2009 (PDF)
Motion for an Order for Particulars - Decision - (PMPRB-07-D3-QUADRACEL and PENTACEL), November 16, 2007 (PDF)
Motion for Production of Contracts - Decision - (PMPRB-07-D2-QUADRACEL and PENTACEL), November 16, 2007 (PDF)
Decision - (PMPRB-07-D1- QUADRACEL and PENTACEL), July 27, 2007 (PDF)
Application for leave to intervene by GlaxoSmithKline Inc. (PDF)

Notice of Hearing (PDF)

Statement of Allegations of Board Staff (Severed)

Schedule of Events (Revised) (PDF)

Top of page

Q

QUADRACEL

Decisions – Board Order

Board Order - (PMPRB-07-D6-QUADRACEL and PENTACEL), June 14, 2012 (PDF)
Decision - (PMPRB-07-D6-QUADRACEL and PENTACEL), June 14, 2012 (PDF)
Judicial Review
- Federal Court Decision - Justice Gauthier (2011 FC 859), July 12, 2011
Board Order - (PMPRB07-D5-QUADRACEL and PENTACEL), March 16, 2010 (PDF)
Decision on the Merits - (PMPRB-07-D5-QUADRACEL and PENTACEL), as amended March 1, 2010 (PDF)
Decision on the Merits - (PMPRB-07-D5-QUADRACEL and PENTACEL), December 21, 2009 (PDF)
Motion for an Order for Particulars - Decision - (PMPRB-07-D3-QUADRACEL and PENTACEL), November 16, 2007 (PDF)
Motion for Production of Contracts - Decision - (PMPRB-07-D2-QUADRACEL and PENTACEL), November 16, 2007 (PDF)
Decision - (PMPRB-07-D1- QUADRACEL and PENTACEL), July 27, 2007 (PDF)
Application for leave to intervene by GlaxoSmithKline Inc. (PDF)

Notice of Hearing (PDF)

Statement of Allegations of Board Staff (Severed)

Schedule of Events (Revised) (PDF)

Top of page

R

RATIOPHARM INC.

Decisions – Board Order

Decision/Reasons - (PMPRB-08-D3-ratiopharm), June 30, 2011 (PDF)
Board Order - (PMPRB-08-D3-ratiopharm) June 30, 2011 (PDF)

Notice of Hearing (PDF)

Notice of Application (PDF)
Schedule of Events (PDF)

RATIO-SALBUTAMOL HFA

Decisions – Board Order

Board Order - (PMPRB-08-D4-ratio-Salbutamol HFA), December 19, 2011 (PDF)
Board Order - (PMPRB-08-D3-ratio-Salbutamol HFA), October 17, 2011 (PDF)
Decision/Reasons - (PMPRB-08-D3-ratio-Salbutamol HFA), May 27, 2011 (PDF)
Decision/Reasons - (PMPRB-08-D2-ratio-Salbutamol HFA) - Preliminary Motions May 2009 - August 14, 2009 (PDF)
Board Order - (PMPRB-08-D2-ratio-Salbutamol HFA) - Preliminary Motions May 2009 - August 14, 2009 (PDF)
Subpoena - (PMPRB-08-D2-ratio-Salbutamol HFA), August 14, 2009 (PDF)
Preliminary Motions - (PMPRB-08-D1-ratio-Salbutamol HFA), November 28, 2008 (PDF)

Notice of Hearing (PDF)

Statement of Allegations of Board Staff (Severed)
Schedule of Events - REVISED September 24, 2008 (PDF)
Press Release (PDF)

REMICADE

Voluntary Compliance Undertakings

Voluntary Compliance Undertaking - March 18, 2003 (PDF)

Decisions – Board Order

Press Release (PDF)
Board Order (PDF)
Joint Submission (PDF)
D1 - Application for Leave to Intervene - February 17, 2003 (PDF)

Decisions – Board Order

Voluntary Compliance Undertaking - June 1, 2007 (PDF)
Board Order - (PMPRB-06-D1-RISPERDAL CONSTA), June 4, 2007 (PDF)

Notice of Hearing (PDF)

Statement of Allegations of Board Staff (PDF)

Top of page

S

SANDOZ CANADA INC.

Decisions – Board Order

Decision on the publication, in full, of the August 1, 2012 Board Decision on the Merits, October 1, 2012 (PDF)

Board Order - (PMPRB-10-D2-SANDOZ), August 1, 2012 (PDF)
Decision/Reasons - (PMPRB-10-D2-SANDOZ), August 1, 2012 (PDF)

Notice of Hearing (PDF)

Notice of Application (PDF)
Schedule of Events – Revised (PDF)

SOLIRIS

Notice of Hearing (PDF - 179 Kb)

Statement of Allegations of Board Staff (PDF - 27 Kb)
News Release
Request an Extension of the Deadline – February 6, 2015 (PDF – 35 Kb)
Request for an Extension to File the Response – February 10, 2015 (PDF – 229 Kb)
Notice of Appearance – February 11, 2015 (PDF – 42 Kb)
Order Regarding Scheduling – February 13, 2015 (PDF - 182 Kb)
Response: March 9, 2015 (PDF – 1,102 Kb)
Appearance by Minister: March 9, 2015 (PDF – 60 Kb)
Request an Extension of the Deadline: March 11, 2015 (PDF – 37.5 Kb)
Order Regarding Scheduling: March 13, 2015 (PDF – 181 Kb)
Note to Parties Regarding Notice and Service: March 13, 2015 (PDF – 179 Kb)
Request an Extension of the Deadline: March 17, 2015 (PDF – 108 Kb)
Objection to Amendment of Ministers' Appearance: March 20, 2015 (PDF – 620 Kb)
Order Regarding Scheduling: March 26, 2015 (PDF – 186 Kb)
Order Regarding Confidentiality: March 26, 2015 (PDF – 184 Kb)
Affidavit of Eric Lun: April 1, 2015 (PDF - 1 MB)
Amended Notice of Appearance: April 2, 2015 (PDF - 184 Kb)
Reply: April 10, 2015 (PDF - 412 Kb)
Order Regarding the Pre-Hearing Conference: May 1, 2015 (PDF - 125 Kb)
Motion for leave to intervene: May 12, 2015 (PDF - 370 Kb)
Motion for Interlocutory Relief: May 15, 2015 (PDF - 7 MB)
Written Submissions accompanying a Motion for Interlocutory Relief: May 22, 2015 (PDF - 1.7 MB)
Order Regarding Scheduling: May 26, 2015 (PDF -183 Kb)
Written Submissions on the Motion for Leave to Intervene: May 29, 2015 (PDF - 2.5 MB)
Respondent’s written submissions in response to motion to intervene: May 29, 2015 (PDF - 1.58 MB)
B.C. response to respondent’s Notice of Motion: June 5, 2015 (PDF - 2.27 MB)
Written submissions filed by CLHIA: June 5, 2015 (PDF - 244 kb)
Replies filed by the respondent
- Reply to Board Staff: June 12, 2015 (PDF - 1.02 MB)
- Reply to British Columbia: June 12, 2015 (PDF - 1.72 MB)
- Reply to CLHIA: June 12, 2015 (PDF - 462 kb)
Order regarding particulars and regarding the calendar: June 23, 2015 (PDF - 183 kb)
Amended Notice of Appearance: June 26, 2015 (PDF - 325 kb)
Amended respondent’s response: July 17, 2015 (PDF - 3.18 MB)
Order regarding scheduling: August 5, 2015 (PDF - 782 kb)
Respondent’s motion pertaining to a conflict of interest: August 21, 2015 (PDF - 1.76 MB)
Respondent’s motion pertaining to the disclosure of documents: August 21, 2015 (PDF - 1.27 MB)
Respondent’s motion to strike portions of B.C. further amended notice of appearance: August 21, 2015 (PDF - 838 kb)
Affidavit of Anna Di Domenico: August 21, 2015 (PDF - 4.87 MB)
Amended reply: September 1, 2015 (PDF - 393 kb)
Written Representations of the Respondent: Alexion’s motion re: Conflicts of interest: September 2, 2015 (PDF - 2 MB)
Written Representations of the Respondent: Alexion’s motion re: Disclosure of documents: September 2, 2015 (PDF - 2 MB)
Written Submissions of the respondent: (Alexion’s Motion re: Strike Portions of the Further Amended Notice of Appearance Filed by the Minister of Health): September 2, 2015 (PDF - 3 MB)
Chairperson’s Motion for leave to intervene: September 8, 2015 (PDF - 1 MB)
ALEXION'S WRITTEN REPRESENTATIONS (Board Staffs Motion to Strike Paragraphs 37 and 38 of the Amended Response and Alexion's Motion to Strike Paragraph 7 and the Amended Portion of Paragraph 9 of the Amended Reply): September 9, 2015 (PDF - 2 MB)
Written Representations of Board Staff in response to Alexion’s motion re: conflict of interest relating to Mary Catherine Lindberg: September 11, 2015 (PDF - 394 kb)
Written Representations of Board Staff (alleged conflict of Isabel Jaen Raasch): September 11, 2015 (PDF - 718 kb)
Responding Motion Record of Board Staff (Alleged Conflict of Isabel Jaen Raasch) : September 11, 2015 (PDF - 382 kb)
Written submissions, responding to Alexion’s conflict of interest motion by counsel for Mary Catherine Lindberg: September 14, 2015 (PDF - 390 kb)
Supplementary Written Representations of the Respondent in response to the Chairperson’s submissions: September 15, 2015 (PDF - 1.39 MB)
Board Decision – Motion Relating to Conflicts of Interest: October 5, 2015 (PDF - 241 kb)
Response of the Minister of Health of B.C. (Motion of the Respondent to strike portions of the Further Amended Notice of Appearance of the Minister of Health of B.C.): October 19, 2015 (PDF - 446 kb)
Response of Board Staff (Motion of the Respondent to strike portions of the amended reply of Board Staff): October 19, 2015 (PDF - 4.30 MB)
Response of Board Staff (Motion of the Respondent to strike portions of the further Amended Notice of Appearance of the Minister of Health of B.C.): October 19, 2015 (PDF - 5.14 MB)
Reply of Board Staff (Motion of Board Staff to strike portions of the Amended Response of the Respondent): October 19, 2015 (PDF - 4.44 MB)
Response of Board Staff (Motion of the Respondent for disclosure): October 19, 2015 (PDF - 2.66 MB)
Reply of the respondent (motion to strike portions of the Minister of Health of B.C.’s further amended notice of appearance): October 23, 2015 (PDF - 1.71 MB)
Reply of the Respondent (motion to strike portions of the amended reply of Board Staff): October 23, 2015 (PDF - 1.35 MB)
Reply of the Respondent (motion for disclosure): October 23, 2015 (PDF - 994 kb)
Further written submissions of the Respondent (Board Staff's Motion to Strike Paragraphs 37 and 38 of the Amended Response): October 23, 2015 (PDF - 502 kb)
Board Decision – Various Motions Related to Procedural Matters: November 24, 2015 (PDF - 177 kb)
Surreply of the Respondent: December 4, 2015 (PDF - 687 kb)
Scheduling order of the Board: December 7, 2015 (PDF - 90 kb)
Notice of Motion of the Respondent to Strike Evidence as Inadmissible: February 26, 2016 (PDF - 1.05 MB)
Written representations of the Respondent pertaining to the Motion to Strike Evidence as Inadmissible: March 8, 2016 (PDF - 1.98 MB)
Written representations of Board Staff pertaining to the Motion to Strike Evidence as Inadmissible: March 8, 2016 (PDF - 12.4 MB)
Reply of the Respondent pertaining to the Motion to Strike Evidence as Inadmissible: March 16, 2016 (PDF - 3.07 MB)
Board Decision – Motion to Strike Evidence as Inadmissible: March 29, 2016 (PDF - 217 kb)